The Pilgrimage as Healing: Walking Together in Catholic Mental Health

Somewhere in rural Pennsylvania, a group of pilgrims walks the Father Bill Atkinson Pilgrimage, named for the Augustinian priest left a quadriplegic after a swimming accident in 1963 and whose cause for canonization is now open. They carry whatever weight they arrived with. Through the ritual of shared movement across real terrain, they begin — quietly, often without announcement — to change.

The National Catholic Register recently noted that 'a powerful component of pilgrimage can be traveling with others.' That observation deserves more than a passing mention. It is the center of gravity around which the entire therapeutic and spiritual logic of pilgrimage turns.

Why movement matters

The connection between physical movement and psychological wellbeing is well-documented. A 2018 meta-analysis in JAMA Psychiatry found that physical activity was associated with a 35% lower risk of depression across 49 studies and more than 266,000 participants. Stanford research has shown that walking in natural environments reduces activity in the subgenual prefrontal cortex, the region associated with rumination.

Pilgrimage does not simply involve walking. It involves walking with intention, across distance, in relation to a destination that carries meaning beyond the self. The body moves within a narrative framework that restructures how the walker understands time, suffering, and belonging. Catholic anthropology has always insisted on this integration: body and soul constitute a single reality, and what acts on one acts on both.

Pilgrimage and Transcendence

Pilgrimage works therapeutically not despite its religious structure but because of it. The shared intentionality — the recognition among companions that the journey has been undertaken for reasons that transcend personal preference — functions as a pre-established covenant. This is not merely social bonding. It is what Francis calls 'mystical fraternity,' a contemplative way of being with others that sees the sacred in the neighbor and finds healing precisely in that recognition.[^1]

Biological anthropology offers a partial account. Walking side by side, rather than face to face, reduces the social threat response and facilitates honest disclosure. The removal of direct eye contact, combined with a shared forward orientation toward a common goal, creates conditions in which difficult material becomes more accessible and less defended. But the secular account stops there. The Catholic account adds that the pilgrim walks not merely because walking is good for the body but because something greater is being sought. That shared intentionality changes what the companion is to the pilgrim: not a walking partner, but a fellow searcher, which is a different kind of bond altogether.

Viktor Frankl argued that the primary human drive is meaning, and that the capacity to locate meaning within suffering is the most reliable predictor of psychological survival. Pilgrimage is a technology of meaning-making at the somatic level: the body itself becomes the protagonist of a story about endurance, arrival, and grace. The Catholic tradition goes further, insisting that suffering participates in something real — a redemptive arc oriented toward love. This is a theological claim, but its psychological effects are measurable. Studies of religiously integrated psychotherapy consistently find that treatment approaches congruent with a client's religious worldview produce superior outcomes among those for whom faith is a central identity structure.

Father Atkinson's life embodies the paradox at the heart of this: limitation and transcendence are not opposites but partners. The pilgrimage bearing his name invites walkers to carry their own limitations with them, to place one foot in front of the other not despite struggle but through it. The road does not remove the weight. It gives the weight somewhere to go.

References

[^1]: Pope Francis, Evangelii Gaudium (2013), §92: 'a mystical fraternity, a contemplative fraternity... capable of seeing the sacred grandeur of our neighbour, of finding God in every human being.'