Three Generations, One Roof: What Multigenerational Living Reveals About Us

A House Hunt Worth Noticing

A retired math teacher, her daughter, and her granddaughter recently pooled roughly $1 million to find a home together in New Rochelle, New York. The story, reported by the New York Times, follows their search for a house large enough to hold three generations of women — and a dog named Harry Styles. On the surface, it reads as a real estate column. Look a little deeper, and it becomes something else: a quiet portrait of how families are reimagining what it means to belong to one another across time.

Multigenerational households are growing across the United States, driven in part by housing costs, eldercare needs, and shifting cultural attitudes. But the economic explanation, while real, misses the more interesting story. Something relational is happening here, something that touches on longstanding truths about human beings and what we are built for.

People Are Made for Communion

Human beings flourish in relationship. This is not a therapeutic cliché — it is a structural fact about the kind of creature we are. Psychological research consistently shows that social connectedness is among the strongest predictors of wellbeing across the lifespan. Loneliness, by contrast, carries health risks comparable to smoking. The elderly who remain embedded in family life show slower cognitive decline. Children who grow up with grandparents present demonstrate greater emotional resilience and a richer sense of identity over time.

Catholic Christian anthropology names this reality with precision: the human person is interpersonally relational by nature. We are made not as isolated individuals who occasionally choose community, but as beings whose very identity unfolds in relationship — with family, with friends, with God. The family, in this view, is not a convenience or a social contract. It is the original school of love, the first place where a person learns to give and receive, to sacrifice and be sustained.

Three women choosing to share a home are, in a real sense, choosing each other — and that choice carries weight.

The Wisdom That Moves Between Generations

There is something irreplaceable about what passes between a grandmother and a grandchild in ordinary daily life. It is different from what a parent transmits, and different again from what peers offer. A grandmother brings what might be called lived memory — a perspective seasoned by decades of experience, failure, recovery, and accumulated judgment. A grandchild brings newness, energy, and the particular hopefulness of someone still near the beginning.

When these two inhabit the same house, something moves between them that cannot be scheduled or engineered. It happens in kitchens and over homework and during slow evenings. The child absorbs, almost unconsciously, what it looks like to age with dignity. The grandmother is drawn, almost involuntarily, into continued purpose.

This kind of transmission is one of the great goods of multigenerational life — and one of the great losses of a culture that tends to separate its generations into age-stratified institutions. The retired teacher, the working daughter, the grandchild: each is at a different stage of the human journey. Each has something the others need. Living under one roof creates the conditions where that exchange can happen organically.

Planning as an Act of Love

It is worth pausing on the practical side of what these three women did. They coordinated finances across generations. They assessed needs — space, accessibility, proximity to schools and services. They made a long-term commitment to a shared life. This kind of deliberate foresight — thinking ahead about what each person will need, not just today but five and ten years from now — is itself a form of love made concrete.

Good decisions about how to structure family life require this kind of careful, forward-looking thinking. Who will need care, and when? Who can provide it? What does the child need to flourish? What does the grandmother need to remain engaged and dignified? These are not bureaucratic questions. They are moral ones, and answering them well takes both practical wisdom and genuine concern for the other.

At Presence+, we pay attention to stories like this one because they demonstrate that virtue is not an abstraction. It lives in decisions — including decisions about where and with whom to make a home.

What Gets Healed in These Arrangements

There is also something quietly redemptive about multigenerational living when it is chosen freely and structured with care. Many families carry wounds across generations — patterns of distance, unresolved grievances, habits of disconnection. Choosing proximity does not automatically heal these things, but it creates the conditions where healing becomes possible. Shared meals, ordinary conversation, the texture of daily life together — these are the materials from which reconciliation is built.

There is also healing of a cultural wound. Modern life has exported its elders to facilities and its children to peer groups, sorting human beings by age in ways that impoverish everyone. The multigenerational household, at its best, resists this fragmentation. It holds together what the broader culture has pulled apart.

Practical Encouragements for Families Considering This Path

For families drawn to this kind of arrangement, a few honest observations:

Clarity about roles and expectations matters from the start. Who makes decisions about the shared space? How are costs divided? What privacy does each person need? These conversations, though sometimes uncomfortable, are acts of respect — they honor each person's legitimate needs rather than leaving them unspoken.

Design the space to support both togetherness and solitude. Human beings need both. A home that forces constant proximity without refuge can strain even the most loving relationships. A thoughtful floor plan is a form of wisdom applied to stone and wood.

Allow the arrangement to evolve. The grandmother who is active and independent today may need more care in five years. The grandchild who is young now will eventually need more autonomy. Commitments made with flexibility built in tend to last longer than rigid ones.

Celebrate the ordinary. Shared dinners, holiday rituals, the small ceremonies of daily life — these are not peripheral to the project of family. They are the project. Protecting them against the relentless busyness of modern life is worth the effort.

A Life Lived Together

The women in New Rochelle were searching for a house. What they were really doing was choosing a way of life — one that keeps them accountable to one another across the years, that gives the youngest member of their family a living inheritance of memory and love, and that gives the oldest a continuing place in the story.

Human beings are made for exactly this kind of belonging. The evidence from psychology and the wisdom of the Christian tradition converge on the same insight: we do not flourish alone. A home that holds three generations is, in its ordinary and imperfect way, an image of something true about us.